Skip to main content

Book Review: Agastya - Anuradha Gajraj Lopez

 


This book was released by Subbu recently, which piqued my interest. Agastya Muni (as he is commonly referred to) is a very revered saint in the southern parts of Bharathavarsha and naturally I was attracted to this work. Overall, I feel the first half of the book is a good introduction to those unfamiliar with the stories, legends and history associated with Agastya muni. The second half of the book is a fan account of one of the prominent Kalari teachers of modern era and culminates with the author’s personal encounters with the revered sage. The author’s father is said to have been a medium to encapsulate the teachings of the great saint which is captured in the last part of the book.

There are quite a few aspects of the book which I differ with and I try to capture my observations as below:

  • Timeline of Ramayana and Vedic period as captured by the author is incorrect. Vedic is much more older and Ramayana is quite old
  • Quantifying Ramayana and Mahabharatha as epic diminishes their importance - They are our Itihasas (history - as it happened)
  • Between pages 20-22, there is a general commentary which is quite irrelevant and quite well known. I couldn’t comprehend the reason for the same.
  • Mitra is termed as God of Honesty and Friends. In general, Mitra along with Varuna (as in Maitra-Varuna) guard the world and uphold the truth and light - holding oath holders on their oaths and watching their actions
  • The stories of Agastya drinking the ocean or one associated with Vindhya mountains is not completely presented. Its seems rushed up. 
  • Parashurama - is termed as a Mythological figure. I presume with the awakened consciousness, we could definitely phrase this much better
  • There are many paragraphs which seem to be repeated in quick vicinity. A good review could easily save some pages off this book.
  • The author quotes some of the criticism received and subsequent response to the same - I feel that the response could have been a tad better
  • There is a lot of self promotion by the author - I published this, I published that etc. At times, it becomes a hurdle in the study flow.
  • Shivaratri - The author quotes this as the day of worshipping Shiva. However, it needs to be highlighted that there is a masika Shivaratri and Maha Shivaratri (Phalguna Sukla Chaturdashi) is the one that was alluded to by the author
  • Transliterations of the writings is very good. However, the appeal of the same to wider public is something I am not very clear as the language is Tamil which may not be understood by non-Tamil speakers


Lastly, I am disappointed at the attempt to secularise the concepts and teachings of Thiru. I am not sure about the intention behind secularising every single aspect of the Sanatana Dharma. Quite frankly, this could have been avoided.



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Movie Review: Su from So - My take

                                                                    (Pic Credit: Wiki) Su from So or rather Sulochana from Someshwara is a blockbuster movie running in the theatres to house full shows. And for good reason.. This is a masterpiece .. an absolute masterclass in story telling, script and layering of multiple nuances in the most simplistic of situations. There are reviews galore and it would be absolutely useless to write a review about the movie. However, after coming out of the movie hall, I reflected on the movie and the undertones of the various characters (specifically the emotional arcs) embedded brilliantly into the narrative. This is my attempt to capture some thoughts rummaging through my mind as I walked out of the theatre. Small mistakes have huge snowball consequences Ashoka makes a mistake. To ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Temple Circuit : Haasanmba - Doddagaddavalli - Hiremagalur - Belavadi - Javagal

A spur of the moment decision, next I know we are planning or rather packing for this day trip to have the darshana of the very divine Hasaanamba Devi. Multiple attempts in the previous year landed up with disappointments and hence, I was eager to have her darshana this time around. Along with a couple of my colleagues, the family of one of them joined us in this trip. It was such a blessing to be in the presence and to listen to the timeless wisdom of the elders of the group. The entire trip was a very happy family experience, with the elder couple caring for all of us as their own children.   
We started from Bengaluru around 5:45 am. Enroute we stopped at MTR on Bengaluru - Hassan highway and treated ourselves to a sumptuous breakfast. Food is really good here !!! Haasanamba Temple 
A very divine temple nestled within the Haasan city, a much revered Devi whose darshana is available only for a specific period in a year. First and the foremost, we need to thank the Government, di...
1 comment
Read more

In Memorium : S. L. Bhyrappa

 Words are just insufficient to describe the sense of loss of a great person for the country, for the society and personally for me. One of my friends asked me to speak about SLB sir, but no matter how hard I tried, mind didn’t cooperate. Perhaps, it required some sinking in about the loss of an individual as accomplished, influential master like him. I am sure there are many more accomplished writers and authors who have worked closely with SLB sir and have written eloquently about the great man. I tried to put to words what impact he had on me in my life. To describe S. L. Bhyrappa in words is to attempt to describe an ocean holding a fistful of water. The impact of his words on his audience was very individual, but highly impactful. I found SLB sir quite late (on relative terms) in my life. Though I had heard and read about him in papers, I never took up the courage to go and start reading his books. Perhaps, it was providence that I found his writings at a time when I was searc...
Post a Comment
Read more